A cracked screen or dead battery doesn't mean your Apple Watch is worthless — broken devices still fetch real cash from the right buyers. Data from BankMyCell shows that even heavily damaged Apple Watches can return $20–$150+ depending on model and condition. Whether you prefer a quick local sale or want to compare offers online, knowing where to sell matters. Check out our guide to top selling platforms and tips for selling locally online to maximize your return. Ready to get started?
Quick Answer
You can sell broken Apple Watches on eBay, Swappa, or Decluttr online, or locally via Facebook Marketplace and Craigslist. Buyback services like BankMyCell or Gazelle also accept damaged devices. Even heavily damaged models can return $20–$150+ depending on the model and condition.
Jump to
Summary Table
| Item Name | Price Range | Best For | Website |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shopify | $19–25/month | E-commerce Entrepreneurs | Visit Site |
| SellCell | $20–$200+ | Getting the highest offer by comparing 40+ buyers | Visit Site |
| SmartphonesPLUS | $15–$150 | Fast instant quotes with free shipping | Visit Site |
| PayMore | $10–$120 | Same-day in-store cash payouts | Visit Site |
| WeBuyBackElectronics | $10–$130 | Sellers wanting a straightforward online buyback | Visit Site |
| BuyBackWorld | $15–$160 | Reliable mail-in with multiple payment options | Visit Site |
| CellCashr | $10–$100 | Quick cash for heavily damaged or dead watches | Visit Site |
Broken Apple Watch Guide: 7 Best Places to Sell (2026)
Below you'll find detailed information about each aspect, including important details and considerations.
1. Shopify
If you have multiple broken Apple Watches to offload, setting up a Shopify store lets you list and sell damaged devices directly to buyers — including repair shops, parts collectors, and hobbyists — without relying on a middleman. You control pricing, and even a non-functional watch can attract buyers looking for components like bands, casings, or displays. Plans start at $19–25/month with a 3-day free trial.
Key details:
- Plans from $19–25/month (Basic tier)
- 3-day free trial — no upfront commitment
- Best for: Entrepreneurs selling multiple units or building a used-electronics resale business
2. SellCell
SellCell is a comparison site that aggregates buyback offers from dozens of vendors, making it one of the fastest ways to find the best payout for a broken Apple Watch. Rather than manually checking each buyback site, you enter your watch model and condition, and SellCell surfaces the top offers side by side. This is especially useful for damaged devices, where prices vary significantly between buyers.
What you get:
- Instant price comparisons across 40+ buyback vendors
- Free to use — no fees or commissions
- Covers all Apple Watch series, including faulty or cracked units
3. SmartphonesPLUS
SmartphonesPLUS is a resale and trade-in service that accepts Apple Watches in less-than-perfect condition, making it a practical option for owners of faulty or physically damaged watches. According to SmartphonesPLUS, getting a quote is straightforward — you describe the device's condition, receive an offer, and ship it in. Payouts are typically competitive for broken devices compared to general marketplaces where broken listings often go unsold.
Notable perks:
- Accepts damaged, cracked, and non-functional Apple Watches
- Simple quote process with prepaid shipping
4. PayMore
PayMore is a retail buyback chain that accepts broken Apple Watches in-store, making it a strong option if you prefer an instant, face-to-face transaction over shipping your device. They evaluate your watch on the spot and pay cash or store credit immediately, so there's no waiting for mail-in quotes or buyer offers. With locations across the U.S., this works well for sellers who want same-day payment without dealing with online listings or shipping logistics.
Key details:
- In-person appraisal — no shipping or waiting required
- Accepts damaged, cracked, and non-functional Apple Watches
- Instant cash or store credit payout
5. WeBuyBackElectronics
WeBuyBackElectronics is a mail-in buyback service that purchases damaged and non-working Apple Watches directly from sellers. You submit your device details online to get an instant quote, then ship your watch free of charge. It's a practical choice for sellers who want a no-hassle payout without listing fees, buyer negotiations, or marketplace accounts to manage.
What to expect:
- Free prepaid shipping label provided after quote acceptance
- Payment issued via check or PayPal after device inspection
- Quotes available for broken, cracked, or water-damaged models
6. BuyBackWorld
BuyBackWorld lets you trade in a faulty or damaged Apple Watch through a straightforward online quote system — enter your model and condition, accept the offer, and ship it free. According to BankMyCell, dedicated buyback platforms like BuyBackWorld often return competitive payouts even on non-functional devices compared to peer-to-peer marketplaces. Payments are typically sent within a few business days of device receipt and inspection.
Notable perks:
- Free prepaid return shipping included
- Accepts broken and heavily worn Apple Watch models
- Payment via check, PayPal, or store credit
7. CellCashr
CellCashr is a buyback service that accepts damaged and non-functioning Apple Watches, making it a practical option for anyone looking to offload a broken device for cash. You submit your watch details online, receive an instant quote, and ship it in for payment — no repair required before selling.
What to know:
- Accepts broken, cracked, and water-damaged Apple Watch models
- Free shipping label provided after quote acceptance
- Payment issued via check or PayPal once device is received and inspected
Final Words
Your best bet depends on how fast you need payment and how much effort you're willing to put in — local buyers offer speed while online platforms often pay more. Whether you're new to selling used items online or a seasoned seller, one of these seven options will match your situation perfectly.